Retail Transformers brings you candid conversations with the people reshaping the future of commerce - the crazy ones, the rebels, the innovators, the disruptors, and the bold thinkers. Stay Sharp. Be Bold. Transform Retail!
Missed the last issue?
Your ad worked. A shopper saw it, liked the product, maybe even added it to cart. Then they opened ChatGPT and typed: “What’s the best moisturizer for my sensitive skin?” If you’re not in that answer, you paid for the click and your competitor got the sale.
Will Shoppers Trust Personal Agents?
Meta launched its Muse personal agent in September. By the time Casey Golden and I got to RetailClub AI Festival a couple of weeks later, personal agents were the new obsession, at least going by the download numbers in the app stores and the buzz that created in the crowds.
So when we sat down with Sabrina McPherson in the Retail Razor recording studio tent, I asked her the question I’d been wanting to ask since the Muse buzz started:
at what level will shoppers really trust these agents to go out and buy for them?
Her first answer: we have a long way to go.
Sabrina is Senior Vice President and Practice Lead for Consumer Products Management Consulting at Publicis Sapient, with more than 20 years working with consumer products companies. We were at an AI festival, so of course we talked agentic commerce. By the end, she’d shown Casey and me that the trust question runs in two directions, and brands control one of them.
VOTE NOW for The Retail Razor in The Retail Voice Award!
The Retail Razor Podcast Network is nominated for The Voice of Retail award at the Vendors in Partnership Awards happening at NRF in January.
You can help us win by voting for us online!
With over 1.3 million views on YouTube, we know your help will put us in the winner’s circle!
Voting is open until THIS FRIDAY, November 20th!
WE NEED YOUR SUPPORT!
Please visit https://go.retailrazor.com/VIPawards27 and vote for us today!
We couldn’t have achieved this recognition without YOU, our loyal fans!
THANK YOU!
The goal is selection now.
Before we got to agents, I asked where brands and retailers should start. Sabrina said the goal has moved. It used to be search: get found. Now it’s selection: get recommended and picked by the AI.
She was telling people traditional search was dead a year ago, and they didn’t want to hear it. Casey asked if anyone had tried searching lately.
Sabrina’s verdict: “It’s a nightmare.”
The part I liked is that brands and retailers want the same outcome here: a purchase that doesn’t come back as a return.
That’s a reason to share product data. The brand explains what makes its product different, beyond price and attributes. The retailer brings what shoppers search for and click on. Put those together and the AI has a reason to pick you.
Context your catalog never had.
Casey’s example made me laugh because it’s true.
ChatGPT doesn’t know Ralph Lauren Purple Label from Blue Label from Double RL. It has no concept of the house, and that context isn’t written down anywhere the AI reads.
Then she pointed out that a wedding dress and a dress for a wedding are two different searches from two different shoppers. Sabrina added the season and the kind of wedding.
Shopping is intent-based now, and as Casey put it, that context was never part of the product catalog.
Sabrina calls this designing for two audiences. People buy on brand, imagery, and how something makes them feel. AI agents want consistent data they can trust, or as Casey said, walls of text. You need both, and the work is translating what makes you different into language a machine can read.
Two layers of trust.
Back to my question. Sabrina’s answer had two layers.
First, shoppers have to believe the AI isn’t just pushing whatever someone paid for.
Right now, they don’t. Sabrina said even on a brand’s own site, she assumes she’s being shown inventory they need to offload. Her line: they’re trying to sell me the day-old eggs, when I want the best egg for my need.
Second, the AI has to trust your data.
If it sees different signals across channels, or doesn’t believe your inventory is accurate, it won’t recommend you. Your product data has to say the same thing everywhere. And Sabrina isn’t the first to raise this point. On The Retail Razor Show, Leslie Ann Hall, Founder and CEO of Iced Media, gave us exactly the same message!
Sabrina doesn’t expect anyone to jump five levels of trust at once. People will try these agents, things will go wrong, and some will walk away saying the agent is hallucinating.
Casey also has a test for which product categories shoppers will actually hand to an agent. I’m leaving that one for the episode. It starts at 12:13.
We’re excited about where live shopping is going!
Where I landed.
Shoppers will get comfortable with agents at their own pace, and no brand can rush that.
The other layer, the AI trusting your data, is work a brand can start today:
product data with real detail,
the same story on every channel,
and inventory the AI can believe.
When we recorded, Casey had looked at plenty of brands that hadn’t started, with holiday 30 to 45 days out. I get why. Nobody wants to sign seven contracts for tools that change every week. But as I said in the tent…
everything is moving so fast that you lose more the longer you wait.
My take: if an AI agent described your product today and got it wrong, that’s a problem you can fix before shoppers are ready to let agentic commerce do their buying.
Watch, listen, subscribe.
🎙️ Season 2, Episode 13 of Retail Transformers: “Agentic Commerce - AI Is Choosing Your Products. Are You Ready?”
Listen wherever you get podcasts or watch on our YouTube channel or Spotify.
Your turn.
If this was useful, subscribe so the next one lands in your inbox.
Next on Retail Transformers: Kelly Goetsch, president of Pipe17, joins us to share his views on agentic commerce!
Comment on this newsletter or join the conversation on LinkedIn! Your insights may help shape the topics we explore next.
Until next time! Stay sharp. Be Bold. And Transform Retail!
Sincerely,
Ricardo Belmar
The Retail Razor: Retail Transformers
Thank You for Your Support!
BIG NEWS! We surpassed 1,300,000 views on our YouTube channel!
A huge THANK YOU to all of you who have been watching every episode on YouTube! We couldn’t have imagined the massive success we’ve had this year on YouTube and we’re incredibly grateful for your support! Cheers 🥂 to all our video fans and here’s to the next million!
We’re also honored to be the #1 Indie Podcast Network for Retail on Goodpods with our shows regularly in the Top 5 of the weekly & monthly Management podcast charts. Plus, the #1 podcast in the weekly & monthly Indie Marketing, Indie Business, and Indie Careers podcast charts.
We’re also excited to have two podcasts ranking in the Top 20 Retail Management podcasts and a Top 3 Retail Careers podcast on Apple Podcasts!
We’d love your support to help us stay at the top with all our shows by giving us a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Goodpods, or Spotify.
The Retail Razor Podcast Network
Retail Transformers is part of the Retail Razor Podcast Network, alongside The Retail Razor Show, Blade to Greatness, and Data Blades. Find us at RetailRazor on LinkedIn, Bluesky, Threads, and Instagram. For a full transcript of this episode, visit our retailrazor.com website!



